Reviews

Newsies (1992)

newsies

(If this is your first time on this blog, I ask you to read my About page first! You can find a link to it at the top left-hand corner of this blog. Thanks!)

In 1992, a musical film directed by Kenny Ortega was released. The film received negative reviews and ended up flopping at the box office, but gained quite a cult following throughout the years.

Sounds utterly familiar!
Sounds utterly familiar!

The popularity of the film was so great that the film was eventually adapted as a proper Broadway musical! So, is this film a hidden treasure that just wasn’t understood or appreciated when it first came out? Or is this film honestly deserving of its initial negative reviews? Let’s find out as we explore the cultural phenomenon that is Newsies!

(This was a request by one of my readers. I forget who it was though, so sorry!)

And remember, SPOILERS AHEAD!

As the film opens in New York City in the 1890s, we see an old somewhat run-down place wherein a whole bunch of young male kids seem to reside. They’re our newsies, our newspaper boys. Their job is to sell and distribute newspapers that moguls like Joseph Pulitzer and William Randolph Hearst print. They’re all of different sizes, races, ages, physical capabilities, etc. The first song of the film, Carrying the Banner, lets us see deeper into the daily lives of these boys.

The leader of the newsies, or at least the one whom the rest of the boys look up the most, is a teenager named Jack Kelly, played by Christian Bale. He’s your typical mischievous guy who has a good heart filled with a sense of justice and an attitude saying that nobody can push him around. He has dreams of leaving the business and heading out west to Santa Fe to form a new life. We hear more of his desires and feelings in the song, Santa Fe.

One day, in an effort to make more profits, Joseph Pulitzer, played by Robert Duvall, increases the price of the newspapers. This affects the newsies as it costs them more to buy papers now and will result in them barely making a living. They’re all upset at this price increase and under the leadership of Jack and another newsie named David, played by David Moscow, they decide to strike! They refuse to sell any more papers until the price goes back to what it was!

It’s not long before the newsies’ strike gets the attention of people including that of a local reporter, Bryan Denton, played by Bill Pullman. He soon joins forces with the boys by publishing their strike in his paper as Pulitzer has banned any mention of the strike in his papers. When that doesn’t quell the strike, Pulitzer uses brute force against the newsies which also backfires. He finally calls Jack up for a man-to-man talk.

newsieschristianbaleandrobertduvall
“I’m gonna make you an offer you can’t refuse! Oh sorry, wrong film!”

Pulitzer basically tempts Jack with his dreams of going to Santa Fe and this surprisingly has an effect on Jack. He soon starts to work again for Pulitzer and is viewed as a sell-out to the other boys. And if that wasn’t enough, Denton can no longer cover the strike as it’s affecting his career with his paper. Then just as quickly as they seemed to change, Jack soon changes his mind and rejoins the strike while Denton decides to help the newsies publish their own newspaper regardless of what it does to his career!

"Well, aren't we the masters of creating and solving conflicts or what?"
“My, don’t we know how to create and solve conflicts quickly!”

The newsies’ newspaper was printed to distribute to kids all over New York City to rally in front of Pulitzer’s office. This last stand of solidarity shown amongst the newsies and the children makes Pulitzer give in and put the price of his newspaper back to what it originally was. All the newsies are happy especially Jack who has a chance now to go to Santa Fe! But, he decides to stay back with his newsies brethren and continue “carrying the banner”!

And that was Newsies. And…I kinda agree with the initial negative reviews that this movie received.

This film reminds me a lot of Pete’s Dragon. It’s an ambitious attempt with potential to be great, but it fails both as a musical and as a film. In terms of the musical aspect, while the choreography is wonderful to watch, I would say many of the songs in this film are forgettable and/or pointless. The only songs that I think are any good in this film are Carrying the Banner, Santa Fe, and King of New York.

In terms of the film aspect, while the film has some nice production design, cinematography, and acting by Christian Bale and the other boys, that’s pretty much the only strong points to the film. The acting of the adults almost all seem like they’re doing it for the paycheck and some appearances, such as that of Ann-Margret, seem entirely pointless!

"I'm not an unsharpened pencil for you to call pointless, sir!"
“I’m not an unsharpened pencil for you to call pointless, sir!”

The story also isn’t strong as it loses focus often. It gets distracted with all these minor appearances by other actors as well as subplots such as attempting to save a fellow newsie from a prison-like orphanage and then not saving him afterwards! I’ve already mentioned how quickly Jack and Denton’s characters change from being “traitors” to back on the side of the newsies! The story is just incredibly loose!

So, I agree with the original reaction to this film when it came out! But, if you want to give a watch, go ahead, just don’t expect Mary Poppins!

(You can click on the image below for an enlarged version of my rating sheet.)

newsiesrating

So, the final score for this film is 21/35 = 60% (D-) !

The next review will be posted on May 23rd.

22 thoughts on “Newsies (1992)

  1. I once tried to watch the movie, but I didn’t make it very far…those songs have some of the worst lyrics I have ever heard. It constantly describes what we see clearly on the screen, no wit, no reason to actually listen to them.

  2. It’s been a long time since I’ve seen this film, though I don’t recall it very well, which might be saying something. I do recall thinking the songs were largely forgettable, though I know a few people who are huge fans. I suspect, however, that it might be because they are fans of Christian Bale.

    I really enjoyed your review!

  3. As I’ve said, I love this film, both from a nostalgia standpoint and the fact that it has some killer songs (along with a healthy dose of duds). They improved a lot for the stage version, trimming out the bad songs and replacing them with vastly improved versions, and really punching up the script and characters. But as an early Menken/Ashman effort, with excellent choreography, production design, and some good performances here and there, I still love it. Plus the nostalgia factor helps me ignore the more grating parts.

    1. Yeah, maybe nostalgia helps. I didn’t grow up with this film and only saw it a few years ago for the first time. I’m interested in seeing the Broadway musical to see the changes they made.

      Was Howard Ashman involved in this film? I thought someone else did the lyrics?

      1. Oh no, you’re right, Ashman wasn’t involved. My bad. You should definitely check out the stage version if it comes to your town.

  4. I’m seeing the Broadway touring version of this in a few weeks so you could say I’m a fan. The adults stuff is bad but the rest of it I find very charming. I guess I’m blinded by nostalgia but oh well. I like it.

    1. Yeah, nostalgia seems to be the reason many people tell me they like the film for. I didn’t grow up with this film; I saw it for the first time a few years ago.

      I’m interested in seeing the Broadway version though to see the changes they make.

      1. Yeah there’s some things I genuinely like and there’s some things I know I like for nostalgia and this is the latter. I don’t think it is terrible or anything but I know it isn’t great either. I’m excited to see the musical. Kind of cool that it went from winning razzies when it came out to Tony awards on Broadway.

  5. I have a friend (also a huge Disney fan) who saw Newsies for the first time quite recently and still found enjoyment in it. I still haven’t seen the film yet, but I am ultimately curious about it. At least you ranked it higher than “Hocus Pocus”, which wasn’t exactly an award winner either.

    Also, it’s a shame this might be Alan Menken’s weakest musical score for Disney, if your review is any indication. Maybe he needed to save his A-game for “Aladdin” and this was more of a side-project.

  6. Never seen this movie, but saw the stage show. I love the stage show and love the story. Love the intimate relationship between Jack and Crutchie in the stage show. So glad that Katherine is in the stage show.

      1. Funny story: I asked for the Newsies Original Broadway soundtrack for Christmas and my Uncle accidentally got me the movie. But did eventually own the soundtrack.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s