(If this is your first time on this blog, I ask you to read my “About” page first! You can find a link to it at the top left-hand corner of this blog. Thanks!)
Walt Disney dabbled with live-action since early on in his career with the “Alice Comedies” from the 1920’s in which he put a real person into an animated world.
Even many of his early feature films were a mixture of animation and live-action such as “Song of the South”, “So Dear to my Heart”, “Victory Through Air Power”, etc.
But his first FULLY live-action film was released in 1950. It was a film about swashbuckling buccaneers and buried treasure…a tale of pirates that we all know and love.
I’m talking about the classic film based on Robert Louis Stevenson’s novel, “Treasure Island”. Let’s look at the film together, shall we?
And remember, SPOILERS AHEAD!
The film opens up to a small inn on the West Coast of England in the year 1765. The inn is run by a woman (she’s unseen…actually there are no women characters in the entire film) and her son, Jim Hawkins, played by Disney wonder boy, Bobby Driscoll.
The inn sees its share of shady characters…mostly seamen asking for rum.
One character in particular is an old pirate by the name of Bones…or Billy Bones…or William Bones…I’m just calling him Bones.
He’s in possession of a map that supposedly leads to the legendary treasure of a pirate named Captain Flint. And because of this, other pirates have been trying to obtain the map from him. On one occasion, they actually manage to invade the inn while Jim is away. They try to find the map, but are unsuccessful.
So where is the map? Apparently, Bones gave the map to Jim earlier on because he knew his end was nearing and got Jim out of the inn before the pirates attacked.
Jim has, on the other hand, managed to get the help of a Squire Trelawney and a Dr. Livesey, played by Walter Fitzgerald and Denis O’Dea, respectively. Together, they rush back to the inn only to find Bones dead and the place ransacked. After showing the squire and doctor the treasure map that Bones gave him, the squire gets an idea.
He decides that they should all hire a crew and go after the treasure themselves. The doctor reluctantly agrees and Jim’s unseen mother (quite surprisingly) allows him to go too.
A few days later, most of the arrangements have been made for the voyage; the only thing needed is to hire a crew, an action that the hired Captain Smollett, played by Basil Sydney, has take personal control over. With nothing else to do, the squire, doctor, and Jim head to a local tavern for some breakfast. The tavern is run by the appointed cook of the expedition, a one-legged man by the name of Long John Silver, played memorably by Robert Newton.
After conversing about the voyage (and flattering the squire a bit), Long John convinces the squire to let him assemble the crew so that they can leave later on that same day. The squire agrees because…you know, all tavern cooks are great assemblers of sea voyage crews.
Once the crew is assembled, the ship is ready to set sail. The problem is that Captain Smollett doesn’t trust the crew assembled by their cook. And to be fair, I wouldn’t trust that crew either. So he tells the squire and the doctor that they should be wary of this crew and keep the true intentions of the voyage (this being a treasure hunt) strictly amongst themselves and the first mate, Mr. Arrow. And that all the firearms be stowed in the Captain’s quarters as a precaution. They all reluctantly agree.
So the ship finally sets sail and we get a montage of ship-sailing…routines.
The journey is uneventful for the most part and Jim develops a close relationship with Long John Silver. Jim helps Long John in the kitchen below deck often and the two spend a lot of time together. Long John even gives Jim a gun to keep as a gift….you know, back in the days when giving a gun to a minor was alright.
One day, Long John decides to make a special pudding, but is out of rum. Jim, eager to help, offers to obtain some rum from the squire without the Captain knowing.
Jim gets the rum for Long John and he makes the pudding with it. Later on, a heavy storm is attacking the ship and all the seamen go above deck to keep the ship afloat. But Long John stays below and offers Mr. Arrow some of the pudding to eat before going back above. Mr. Arrow eats the pudding, and due to the (apparently large amounts of) rum in the pudding as well as the violent teeter-tottering of the ship, falls overboard to his death. And nobody ever discovers that Long John was the one who executed Mr. Arrow’s death sentence.
So as you can see, Long John is actually the bad guy and the crew is composed of his men. He and his men were the ones who ransacked the inn earlier and couldn’t find the treasure map. But when he discovered that this expedition was made in order to find the treasure (the secret got out), he did his best to get him and his crew hired. Their plan was to bide time until Long John gave the order to take over the ship from the captain.
One day, Jim overhears Long John and his men discussing their plans below deck and feels betrayed, after all, he’s developed such a close bond with Long John only to find that Long John is nothing more than a mutinous treasure-hunting pirate. Jim then goes and tells the news to the captain, squire, and doctor.
After discussing the matter (behind closed doors, of course), the captain comes to the conclusion that they’re all safe until the treasure island is found. Meanwhile, they’ll arm themselves in case any of Long John’s men get too impatient and want to take over the ship before Long John gives the command. The captain also tells Jim to continue his friendship with Long John so as to not make him suspicious. Jim reluctantly agrees.
By the way, have you ever wanted to know where the stereotypical “pirate voice” originated from? Well, it came from this movie, in Robert Newton’s performance as Long John, to be precise. There have been many pirate movies made before this, of course, and many of the pirates spoke in British accents.
But in this film, Robert Newton used an exaggerated form of his native West Country British accent which became the “Arr, matey”-type pirate voice that we know today. This performance would become the basis of future pirate voices and Robert Newton would become the patron saint of “Talk Like a Pirate Day”. So, if you’re a fan of the pirate voice, you have Walt Disney and Robert Newton to thank for it.
Finally, the day arrives in which the island is spotted. And as predicted, Long John’s mutiny commences. Luckily, the squire, captain, and doctor manage to get the better of most of the men and lock them below deck. Unluckily, Long John escapes on a rowboat with a few of his men and with Jim as a hostage.
As Long John and his men row towards the island, he tells the captain that if he doesn’t surrender himself to Long John’s captured men aboard the ship and hand over the treasure map, then Jim will die. This worries the captain, doctor, and squire who eventually decide to also head to the island (while leaving behind two loyal men to keep watch on the ship) where they think they have a better chance of saving the boy.
And the rest of the movie is pretty much a battle between Long John’s men and the squire, captain, doctor, and Jim for the treasure map. Summing up the events, Jim escapes from Long John’s clutches and is reunited with the squire, doctor, and captain,
the captured men aboard the ship escape from their hold and take over the ship, Long John calls most of the men from the ship to come help him on the island, Jim sneaks aboard the ship and takes over it, the treasure is discovered, and Long John’s men are re-captured.
What about Long John himself? Well, he escapes capture and rows away from the island. And we all feel sympathetic towards him…he’s like Gaston…just a lovable bad guy.
What to say about the film? Well, for the first fully live-action Disney film, it’s not a bad film. But the film can be boring at times especially when compared to the types of films that are around nowadays. The film is also somewhat violent for a 1950 film; it actually now has a PG rating in the USA.
Is there anything good in it? Well yeah, Robert Newton as Long John Silver is amazing to watch. Like I said before, he revolutionized the portrayal of pirates in films, especially regarding their voices. He would reprise his role as Long John Silver in a future (non-Disney made) sequel as well as a TV show about the character. (He also would play Blackbeard the Pirate in a later film.)
All the actors in the film act well, even though some of the characters are quite boring. We can certainly see that this film had many problems; we also see that many of these problems were fixed in future live-action Disney films. For that, we are grateful.
In the end, “Treasure Island” is an important film and one that everyone should see at least once in their lives.
(You can click on the image below for an enlarged version of my rating sheet.)
So, the final score for this film is 26/35 = 74.29% (C) !
24 thoughts on “Treasure Island (1950)”
As a big fan of Treasure Island….I somewhat hate this movie. I hate the stupid pirate voice (not in general, but it doesn’t fit Long John Silver who is a somewhat educated man and speaks that way). I hate the bright colours. I hate the inability of Disney to capture the claustrophobic feelings of the island. I hate this version of Long John Silver (not because of the actor, but because it doesn’t capture the character at all). I hate that they spend so much time on the stupid journey and so few on the island. I hate that so many people remember this thing when they hear “treasure Island” instead of one of the better adaptations.
I don’t think I’ve ever read “Treasure Island”, so I can’t compare it to the book. And I wonder whether this film is really popular and well-known nowadays. I feel that the “Pirates of the Caribbean” franchise has enveloped this film.
Which film/TV adaptation of “Treasure Island” is your favorite…or the one you think portrays it best?
Not counting the ones who do a freer adaptation like Treasure Planet and Schatz im All, providing a new take on the old source material, I think I would go with the Orson Welles version. For me, he is the ultimate Long John Silver, plus the adaptation is so close to the book that it is actually quoting complete scenes out of it, but has as the same time a clear grasp what is important and which part can be skipped over. Then there is also a German fourth-parter which does a very good job with the atmosphere, but I was never quite happy with the actor for Jim.
I dislike most of the newer adaptations since they tend to vilify the British nobles.
I love “Treasure Planet”, but the only other “Treasure Island” adaptation I’ve seen is “Muppet Treasure Island” which I enjoyed.
And you should totally read treasure island…it was my favourite book as a child.
I definitely plan to read it one day. I love classic literature. I’m currently reading “Les Miserables”.
Oh…the complete version? Good luck with that one…it’s huge…
Yeah, it’s around 1400 pages…but I’m enjoying it, so that helps. Unlike “Don Quixote” where I gave up after 200 pages.
Urgh…yeah, Don Quixote is impossible the read. I never managed either.
As you can probably guess, I have not watchd this film (and most of the live-action ones), but I have hears some good things about it. While I watched Treasure Planet and watched other versions of Treasure Island, I never got into the concept, but this is pretty similar to Treasure Planet. I guess I am not into pirates. Good review.
It’s a hard book to adapt, because on the one hand it builds gradually, on the other hand a lot is happening in it. To squeeze this in a single movie is always difficult, one part always fells short, either the start and the travel or the time on the island. And honestly, most adaptation fail to hit a working pacing. There is also the small problem that Jim Hawkins is actually a very bland character, perfect for a book because it is easy to just see yourself in his place, but everything but ideal for a movie.
“Treasure Planet” is far superior than this film, in my opinion.
I HAD A BAD FEELING ABOUT LONG JHON SLIVER I LL WOULD BE SCARD IF HE TRY TO KILLED ME
Like with ‘A Christmas Carol’, the Muppet version of ‘Treasure Island’ was my introduction to the classic story. Even to this day, Tim Curry as Long John is irreplaceable! Having read the book, I do believe this is a decent adaptation (it’s less over the top than the Muppets’ version for starters) and works nicely as a film and I rather enjoyed it (sorry, Swanpride).
While I does show it’s age as a very 50’s film, Robert Newton was a consistently engaging Long John Silver, the action was darker than I was expecting from a Disney production, I was never really bored once even during the long sea voyage scenes. Overall, it’s a great pirate movie and one I can gladly revisit, even if it does show its age. Not quite as funny and peppy as the Muppet film (which I still love) and I’ve yet to see Treasure Island.
Thanks for commenting! It reminds me that I still have to review Muppet Treasure Island someday.
I must confess that I actually really like this film – it was a childhood favorite and Robert Newton was always Long John Silver for me (partially because I saw the movie quite often before reading the book). I might, admittedly, be looking at this film with a biased eye. I’m not always so good at reevaluating films I loved when young. 🙂
I did not know Robert Newton reprised his role quote so often – I wonder if he enjoyed it or if he got tired of it.
He definitely was the ideal Long John Silver. And I feel as long as he was getting paid for it, he didn’t mind reprising his role, lol, but who knows?
The fact that Disney revisited this story twice, over four decades later– once with the Muppets, and the other time in space (and via animation)– makes me think that perhaps TREASURE ISLAND is just one of those films that is so integral to the Disney legacy that they couldn’t just make one and leave it at that.
Mind you, I haven’t seen this version yet (pretty much my only exposure to it has been through the theatrical trailer, featured on the TREASURE PLANET DVD), but personally, compared to the other two versions, I get the feeling it wouldn’t hold up quite as well with me as other older live-action films from the last 50 years or so.
(To tell you the truth, I haven’t seen that many fully live-action films [from any studio] that were released prior to the 1960’s– pretty much the only one that I remember seeing in its entirety is THE WIZARD OF OZ. And out of all of the films of the sixties that I’ve seen, the only three that I can truly call “classics” are MARY POPPINS, TO KILL A MOCKINGBIRD, and BORN FREE. I guess it’s just my sensibilities that come about from having grown up in the late ’90’s and all through the 2000’s…)
At any rate, while I’m sure that Bobby Driscoll did a fine job as Jim Hawkins, aside from his brief appearance in the live-action intro to the “Pecos Bill” sequence in MELODY TIME, I only really remember him for his turn as the voice of Peter Pan.
I wonder if they’ll ever remake another version of Treasure Island?
There are a lot of Disney gems in the live-action films before the 1960s, but many duds as well.
Yeah, that’s how I know Bobby Driscoll best as well!
I’m a big fan of the book who just watched this one for my own blog yesterday for the first time, and I have to say I really liked how close it stays to the book. It definitely has pacing issues but so does the book. I usually have a hard time following live action movies of this era which really doesn’t bode well, but this one caught my attention and didn’t let go, even if the acting can get a bit dated and I couldn’t understand a word out of George Merry’s mouth. Also agreed that Newton’s performance was phenomenal.
Yeah, it’s definitely one of the better ones of that era.
It was nice to see where it all truly began, Disney live-action wise. Has the charm of Disney and just 50s films done at the time. Long John Silver is definitely a highlight. However, since this was like the third adaption of Treasure Island that I saw, I came to the realization that, aside from Planet, I don’t really like this story at all, it’s just not really interesting and drags like crazy. I’ll still give the Muppets version a try, though, later on.
I think you’ll enjoy the Muppets Treasure Island at least!